85 9.35 pt 2 The Abstract Pensieve: Weird rumour- Harry is Horcrux!

The Abstract Pensieve

Aurors and Marauders Aurors and Marauders

Sunday, November 20, 2005

Weird rumour- Harry is Horcrux!

Harry Potter- Voldemort's Horcrux
No Way!

I recently got the weirdest rumour that Harry Potter is one of Voldemort's horcruxes, and he would have to kill himself at the end.
After mulling over it, I came to the conclusion that I disagree!

Firstly, the reason Harry Potter got the scar is that Voldemort attacked him. And hence HArry could not be a Horcrux Because of the simple reason that Voldemort wouldn't scheme with his followers and keep trying to destroy his own Horcrux!
And Voldemort tries his best to kill off Harry Potter whenever they confront each other (take their meeting in the ministry of magic in OOTP), and do you think that Big V is so foolish that he will himself try and order his followers to destroy his own Horcrux ??!! Come on, he even duelled with Harry in GOF, and did his best to kill him.
All his death eaters keep trying to kill Harry, and get quite close to it. Would they dare touch a piece of their master's soul?

But, nobody can tell what JKR can do. Then also, it will be highly illogical if such a thing is there.

6 Comments:

  • u r correct harry cannot b a horcrux i myself thought that harry was a horcrux
    anuradha khaitan

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:17 AM  

  • it can be that on the night voldemort killed harry's parents and transferred his powers to harry (like parseltoungue), he also unknowingy made a horcrux in harry which he does not know about.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:43 AM  

  • according to me voldy made harry potter his horcrux just unknowingly
    reasons :
    -both are parselmouth
    -harry feels pain in his scar when voldy feels strong emotions whether happiness or hatred
    -harry can see through voldy's mind(& nagini's eyes)though he is as a poor legilimens as i am(or my sister says me myself)
    -harry is exceptionally good in DADA voldy's favourite subject
    ---rest i dont remember now

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:02 AM  

  • i dont think such stupid stuff should b even considered(though ive been foolish enough 2 do so)...HARRY POTTER-VOLDEMORTS HORCRUX.....i would like 2 tell these creative minds dat jk rowlings skull protects brains n not dragon dung(in hp lang)....n plz u pple never in ur wildest od dreamz think of writing a novel...preposterious./

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:58 AM  

  • I totally agree with varun.why would someone goaround killing his own horcrux.It is a treamondous observation.I would also like to add something as dumbledore said it is unwiseto make a horcrux which can think for itselftherefore Voldemort can be killing harry for
    the same reason

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:12 AM  

  • Harry can be horcrux.I agree to anonymous that it could be that Harry is a horcrux & voldemort dont know.after all this is just a magic.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:26 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home